Can a horse ride an astronaut?

A taxonomy of antagonistic Midjourney prompts

JAMES MCCAMMON | JUN 11, 2023

The article "Can a horse ride an astronaut?" discusses the challenges and semantic aspects of image creation using text-to-image systems. The author, James McCammon, examines how provocative and unconventional prompts can lead to amusing and even unexpected errors in image production.

Prompt: “A tree jumping rope”

A tree jumping rope

“A tree jumping rope”

A tree jumping rope

A photorealistic image of a tree character with human features, jumping rope on a sunny day in a park. The tree has muscular limbs, and its trunk bends like a torso. The background shows a playground with children cheering. Natural lighting, detailed textures, dynamic pose, high realism.

A tree jumping rope

A fantasy illustration of a tree character with human limbs, jumping rope on a mystical beach at sunset. The tree's roots lift slightly off the sand with each jump, and it has expressive eyes. The ocean waves crash behind, and the sky glows with warm hues. Surreal elements, vibrant colors, high contrast, imaginative scene.

The research focuses on limitations rather than the progress made in the field.
Some of the examples might be the result of poor prompt formulation rather than necessarily a system failure.
The research does not offer solutions or ways to improve existing systems.
Avocado with purple peel

Avocado with purple peel

Banana with pink peel

Banana with pink peel

Orange with purple peel

Orange with purple peel